A Cosmic Shredder
Aristotle once observed that philosophy only arises where people have secured the necessities of life.[i] In this sense, it seems as if our period, so rich in great events but poor in redeeming them, is not suited for philosophy. In fact, the lack of bold ideas has turned into something of a satirical self-caricature online. On social media, people post memes lamenting this predicament. On the one hand, there is 18th-century philosophy, proudly proclaiming to present the self-evident laws of nature, the cosmos, and being as such. On the other hand, we find a hyper-specific contemporary doctoral dissertation on a footnote in Heidegger’s Being and Time. This meme is funny, but truly, the function of laughter here masks the implicit tragedy. To redeem great events, great ideas are necessary.
German philosopher Ernst Bloch famously started his magnum opus, ‘The Principle of Hope,’ with a series of questions: “Who are we? Where do we come from? Where do we go? What do we await? What awaits us?”[ii] These are certainly the right questions. By all means, we should, today, given the development of technology since the ancient Greeks and even since Bloch wrote these words, be in a much better position to answer them. Yet no grand philosophy has taken hold of our period. Perhaps it is true that every period will yield a different answer, a better, more nuanced insight. But history is no automaton; if anything, it is a trickster, constantly revealing that there are more things in heaven and earth than can be dreamed of by any philosophy. Let us try to take them into account.
In the 1950s, Soviet philosopher Evald Ilyenkov wrote a short work titled “Cosmology of the Spirit.” Despite being a prominent philosopher and prolific author of highly acclaimed texts on dialectics, Spinoza, and Hegel, Ilyenkov was always deemed a problem child by Soviet bureaucracy. This was mainly due to his uncompromising stance: Ilyenkov cared little about the official party line on philosophy. Rather, he cared about truth. He wanted to understand the world as it really was, and philosophy, for Ilyenkov, was a tool to do so. He rigorously studied dialectical materialism, unearthing its radical kernel.[iii]
In his cosmology, Ilyenkov addresses several fundamental questions. One of them was the question, “Where do we go?” New observations in 1929 by Edwin Hubble had innovated our understanding of the universe. Instead of seeing it as a static, immutable whole, Hubble found that galaxies were moving away from each other. Drawing on new theories such as relativity, cosmologists began to embrace dynamic models. Given that the very fabric of the universe (space) was expanding, they extrapolated this expansion to a very early moment in time. However, as it became more likely that some kind of massive event in the past occurred, a dynamic universe also meant that things could change in a way that would herald a potential ‘end’, at least in the sense that life or complex matter would be possible no longer.[iv]
Already in the mid-1800s, scientists had proposed the idea of heat death, a concept according to which steadily increasing entropy—a fact derived from the second law of thermodynamics—would eventually reach a tipping point after which all matter would be torn apart. Like a cosmic shredder, all complex matter would be stripped apart, and its constituent parts would fly around in a never-ending cosmic revel, never again merging to create life.
In the 1950s, Soviet cosmologists discussed this theory. This rather dull perspective caught Ilyenkov’s attention—he wanted to apply the philosophy of dialectical materialism to arrive at a possible answer. The way he did so, however, was so radical that it flew in the face of Soviet dogma and could only be published posthumously. Let us look at what he wrote.
Already in the beginning, Ilyenkov starts out with a sentence so provocative that most would find it completely irreconcilable with Marxism. He writes: “Committing no crime against the axioms of dialectical materialism, one can state that matter constantly possesses thought, constantly thinks itself.”[v] Matter constantly possessing thought? What kind of strange panpsychism is this, you might ask. Yet Ilyenkov is prepared to take on the challenge, as he explains that “this, of course, does not mean that matter in each of its particles at each moment possesses the capacity to think and thinks in its actuality.”[vi]
Ilyenkov is referring to matter as such, viewed as a general thing regardless of time or space. The Marxist definition differs from the definition common in physics—a fact that often causes much confusion. In physics, matter is defined as any substance that takes up space. In dialectical materialism, however, matter is defined as that which exists independently of thought: the totality that exists, independently of whether we think about it or not. Fascinatingly, Lenin himself in 1909 discusses the argument that ‘the atom disappears’, pointing out that massless phenomena in physics, such as electromagnetic fields, exist just as much independently of thought as solid objects, therefore falling squarely under the dialectical materialist definition of matter.[vii]
Following this tradition, Ilyenkov sees matter as the substance everything is made of. And since conscious life has emerged, he concludes that the possibility to engender consciousness (yes, even the necessity to do so under certain conditions that arise in the development of the cosmos), has big ramifications: it means that thinking itself is an attribute of matter. Certainly, you might say, this flies in the face of Marxism. Nonetheless, the following quote, written in 1883 by a quirky German thinker, seems to support Ilyenkov: “we have the certainty that matter remains eternally the same in all its transformations, that none of its attributes can ever be lost, and therefore, also, that with the same iron necessity that it will exterminate on the earth its highest creation, the thinking mind, it must somewhere else and at another time again produce it.”[viii]
Who wrote it, you might ask? None other than Friedrich ‘The General’ Engels. Hold on, you might interject. Yes, this shows that Engels wildly saw thinking as an attribute of matter, but what about the ‘iron necessity’ of its extermination on earth? What is Engels talking about here?
This is a great question, and it goes straight to the heart of our contemplations. Engels, writing this in 1883, discussed the fact that our sun will, at some point, die. The life cycle of our central body is limited. At some point, life will hit a brick wall, and no further development will be possible. Merely “for a short span of time,” will it find “conditions suitable for life, only to be mercilessly exterminated later.” [ix]
Well, golly, you might say, what a bleak perspective. I sure didn’t expect this to come from the co-founder of Marxism. In a sense, it makes his struggle for socialism more understandable. If our time, even as a species, is so limited, we should really try to make the most of it. Yet, more than that, Engels’s perspective was dated here. He missed one simple thing—something not yet imaginable in his period: the possibility of us not only leaving behind our planet, but even our galaxy. Given the development of space travel, we can and must become intergalactic.
Ilyenkov was familiar with this possibility, and it formed part of his main argument regarding the supposed ‘death’ of the universe. He argued that the task of consciousness was to somehow reach a level that would prevent the heat death of the universe. Basing himself on the dialectical notion that everything exists for a reason, or, better yet, that every problem contains in itself the potential of its solution, he argued that the task of consciousness was to attain cosmic consequence. Its task was to prevent the dissolution of the cosmos into frayed indifference. Ilyenkov, therefore, introduces the subjective factor into the question of cosmology. Just as Lenin revealed the wide-ranging implications the subjective factor had in history, Ilyenkov argued that this also pertained to the cosmic scale.
Let us return to the idea of leaving our galaxy. As briefly touched on before, from this idea follows another: there is no eternal and immutable limit to the development of conscious matter. Any such limit to development is but temporary, only a contradiction to be solved in the general dialectic of conscious and unconscious matter. The important lesson is that the very real issue of our sun’s limited lifespan can be resolved through space travel and socialism. There is no reason to assume that an insurmountable, ultimate limit to development exists.
Why Consciousness?
Several other important conclusions follow from the ideas considered so far. Viewing consciousness as an attribute of matter is but another way of saying that matter possesses the potential to develop consciousness. Under the right conditions, consciousness emerges as the result of a complex dialectical process—it is an emergent property of matter.
It is important to note that dialectical materialism, as understood by Engels and Ilyenkov here, does not presuppose consciousness as a teleological necessity. Rather, the argument goes a different way. Seeing that consciousness has emerged, it is a fact that matter, as a substance, possesses the possibility of bringing forth consciousness. It shows that the potential of reaching thought implicitly slumbers within matter. Yet, whether or not it emerges depends on conditions that may or may not arise. There is no ultimate, transcendental force pushing the development of matter besides its own contradictory development.
Hegel once wrote that “God, however, does not remain petrified and dead; the very stones cry out and raise themselves to Spirit.”[x] This quote from Hegel’s Philosophy of Nature foreshadows some of the dialectical insights Engels lays out in his Dialectics of Nature. Yet, for Hegel, the act of the stones raising itself to spirit was obscure. For Hegel, in the stones themselves lies Spirit, not as an unrealized potential, but in an alienated form. This is the difference between Engels and Hegel. Hegel assumes that there was an actual alienated form of Spirit in the material world, only waiting to be unlocked by our thinking consciousness. As we think about the stones and penetrate their being through our mental and scientific processes, we transcend their material character as stones and unlock their inner spirit. Hegel would perhaps say, we return spirit to spirit; we end its alienation, as both our thinking and the alienated thinking in the stone are a part of the general spirit that exists everywhere as a primary substance.
The final goal Hegel envisaged is for absolute spirit to come to itself: a perspective of spirit unalienated from all of its externalizations, absolute spirit brought to itself in a sea of self-understanding. Once there, we would find “comprehended history” which forms “the calvary of absolute spirit, the actuality, truth, and certainty of its throne, without which it would be lifeless solitude; only—from the chalice of this realm of spirits foams forth for Him his own infinitude.”[xi] This certainly sounds very nice. But what does it mean? In fact, this perspective reduces the self-actualization of spirit in the world to a purely mental act. Will the stones actually reach consciousness? No, Hegel might say, never mind the stones as stones, we are not interested in them as stones. We are merely interested in them as episodes of alienated spirit. Once we sublate its alienation, we can simply move on with this bit of spirit, add it to the foamy chalice of spirits, and call it a day.
Ironically, Hegel’s assumption of spirit already existing in matter as an alienated entity reduces his lofty perspective of the actualization of spirit to a mysterious, purely intellectual act that leaves the world largely untouched. This means that the entire world, as it exists, reveals itself as the negative image of thinking; the supposed absolute spirit once again turns into mere self-satisfied rumination. Instead of bravely taking on the world, it succumbs to its own contradictions. What then is the way out?
A Marxist Understanding of Consciousness
When dialectical materialists look at stones, they do not view them as alienated instances of spirit. But there are parallels with Hegel: we do see them as consisting of the same general substance as everything else. The difference is that we do not presume this substance to be thought. The stones exist regardless of whether we think about them, whether we penetrate their secrets, analyze their sediments, or understand the millions of years they have been around.
This, however, does not mean that Marxists do not agree with one fundamental part of Hegel’s thinking. The stones, by way of being a specific form of organization of matter, do possess the potential of being conscious. Or better: as specific forms of organization of matter, they possess the same potential matter always possesses; they possess the potential of being reorganized into a form that would unlock their true potential of being consciousness.
This is the true irony. Dialectical materialism, by abandoning Hegel’s notion of Spirit, presents a way of truly elevating Hegel’s stones to consciousness: by re-arranging them into an organizational form that would bring forth consciousness. After all, our neurons are made of the same kind of atoms that stones are made of.
This presents a radically new perspective: the emergence of consciousness in the cosmos is, as Carl Sagan noted, a process in which elements and organizational forms of matter are brought together to give rise to consciousness. We marvel at the endless expanse of the universe, but, truly, it is the endless expanses of the universe, brought to consciousness in the instances of our consciousnesses, that marvel at themselves. We, truly, are star stuff aware of itself, tiny episodes of the cosmos’s incipient self-understanding. But wait, there’s more.[xii]
As we look into the cosmos and study nature, we face one major restriction. As much as we increase our knowledge and understanding (of which we are, by all means, still at a low level), we can never understand the infinite totality of everything. There is one big reason for that: we are not everything. We are little, tiny blobs of consciousness in a sea of darkness. We stare out into the night sky and see our own negativity; we see the dead, wordless beauty of the endless stars. But as we stare, as our understanding advances, is there not another component to our staring? We stare, but we are also hungry.
What we see as we stare at the night sky is not only a negative picture of dead beauty but also a picture of where we came from. More importantly, however, it is also a picture of where we might go. The specific forms, the stars and planets, space itself, all of matter has one big potential. Elon Musk might call it free real estate. I prefer to call it: an endless sea of matter that possesses the potential of being rearranged into conscious matter.
This is the true irony: by affirming the material, non-conscious, non-spirit reality of the material world, we simultaneously affirm its potential to be rearranged into conscious matter. How would this work? What is even being proposed here?
I argue that this is the true task of humanity. Ilyenkov envisaged humanity’s final act as one in which consciousness takes a cosmic stand and reverses entropy, thereby bringing cosmic development back to a pre-consciousness level. And time and time again, new cycles of entropy force us to, once again, rise to the height of the task, prevent the heat death of the universe, and save the world. This sounds fascinating but also repetitive, and, frankly, it introduces another limit to the development of consciousness through the back door.
Overcoming the Contradiction
I believe the task of consciousness is not only to save the universe from entropy, but rather, to realize the infinite potential now lying dormant in the totality of matter. The task is to rearrange all sticks and stones, all stars and cosmic marvels, into conscious structures. Ironically, this also addresses the question of digital consciousness and AI. Consciousness is not merely a mental act; it is the coming-to-consciousness of matter, it is a process that is necessarily rooted in the material transformation of the world. If anything, our current fear of AI stems from the alienated and idealistic way we understand consciousness. This makes sense, as we live in class society, where intellectual labor is clearly separated from manual labor.
But consciousness is not merely intellectual; it is the dialectical unity of the intellectual and the manual. The task, therefore, is to transform unconscious matter into conscious matter, thereby, in fact, negating matter. It is the negation of purely external matter, by which the central contradiction between subject and object, between thinking and the world, is truly overcome. As the contradiction between conscious and unconscious reality is overcome, the idea Hegel could only grasp as a shadow image can be truly realized: materialism itself is negated, and consciousness becomes the generalized form of being. Yet in becoming so, it itself loses its one-sided character, and a higher contradiction between new, higher phenomena (something beyond consciousness) can initiate a new dialectical journey, far beyond what we can imagine in our current period. This, I claim, is the true task of consciousness.
From this follows a central conclusion: It is absolutely paramount that we bring our mode of production, the anarchic capitalist mode of production, to consciousness by replacing it with a socialist system based on world councils. The masses must themselves take control of the production process and consciously decide what to produce, rather than leave it to blind market forces. In this sense, socialism will mark the beginning of the transition from the realm of necessity to the realm of freedom, as Engels called it.[xiii]
As humanity starts to build communism, we will need to develop forms of intergalactic space travel, build Dyson spheres, become what Soviet Astrophysicist Nikolai Kardashev referred to as a Type III civilization, and spread conscious matter to all parts of the universe, eventually becoming a Type IV civilization.[xiv] Dialectical materialism argues that the universe is infinite, which means that our role alone will not be enough to bring an infinite universe to consciousness—life everywhere in the universe must reach the height of conscious matter and only through a collaborative effort on an infinite scale affecting the infinite totality of the universe, will it be possible to elevate the totality of matter to consciousness and solve the central contradiction of the cosmos. And above this ridge, new peaks will rise.[xv]
Notes:
[i] Aristotle, Aristotle’s Metaphysics, trans. W.D. Ross (Oxford University Press, 1924), 115.
[ii] Ernst Bloch, Werkausgabe. 5. Das Prinzip Hoffnung, Kap. 1 – 32 (Suhrkamp Verlag, 1990), 1. My translation.
[iii] Evald Ilyenkov, “Cosmology of the Spirit,” Stasis 5, no. 2 (2017): 164–90.
[iv] Edwin Hubble, “A Relation between Distance and Radial Velocity among Extra-Galactic Nebulae,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 15, no. 3 (1929): 168–73, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.15.3.168.
[v] Evald Ilyenkov, “Cosmology of the Spirit,” 165.
[vi] Evald Ilyenkov, “Cosmology of the Spirit,” 165.
[vii] W.I. Lenin, Materialismus Und Empiriokritizismus, 9th edition (Dietz Verlag, 1970), 258–60.
[viii] Friedrich Engels, Dialectics of Nature, 2nd rev. ed. (Progress Publishers, 1954), 39.
[ix] Friedrich Engels, Dialectics of Nature, 39.
[x] G.W.F. Hegel, Enzyklopädie Der Philosophischen Wissenschaften. II. (Suhrkamp Verlag, 1986), §247 Zusatz. German Original: “der Gott bleibt aber nicht versteinert und verstorben, sondern die Steine schreien und heben sich zum Geiste auf.” Note that the German original uses the word aufheben (sublate). My translation.
[xi] G.W.F. Hegel, Phenomenology of Spirit, trans. A.V. Miller (Motilal Banarsidaas Publishers, 1998), 493.
[xii] Carl Sagan, The Cosmic Connection (Anchor Press/Doubleday, 1973), 190.
[xiii] Friedrich Engels, “Anti-Dühring,” in Marx Engels Werke. 20. (Dietz Verlag, 1968), 264.
[xiv] N. S. Kardashev, “Transmission of Information by Extraterrestrial Civilizations.,” Soviet Astronomy 8 (October 1964): 217–21, NASA Astrophysics Data System.
[xv] Leon Trotsky, Literature and Revolution (George Allen & Unwin Ltd., 1925), 256.